A Nation of Nations

Because I so thoroughly enjoy the randomness of politics, I've decided to tackle the latest controversy in the House of Commons: Quebec as a Nation.

A motion was introduced recently by the Bloc Quebecois to recognize Quebec as a nation, but does not add any further specifications or conditions. Prime Minister Harper replied yesterday that he would introduce his own motion to recognize Quebec as a nation "within a united Canada."

"Our position is clear. Do the Quebecois form a nation within Canada? The answer is yes. Do the Quebecois form an independent nation? The answer is no and will always be no."
- Prime Minister Stephen Harper

Bloc Quebecois leader Gilles Duceppe fired back today that Quebec should be recognized as a nation "that is currently within Canada." He accused the PM of using "partisan tactics" to sway members of the House.

"Never should the existence of the Quebec nation be subjected to what your preferred option is."
- BQ Leader Gilles Duceppe

The Liberals have agreed to support Harper on his motion. However not all MPs agree with it. Some say this may open the door to other "nations," such as Acadia, Newfoundland, etc. Others are unsure this is the correct approach to the situation, stating that Canada is not a nation of nations.

"Are we in Canada to be a nation of nations?"
- Liberal MP Jim Karygiannis

Jack Leyton and his NDP party have agreed to support both motions. WTF?! Typical cop-out, neutral position and I suppose this shouldn't come as too much of a surprise.

I am of the opinion that while this is better than allowing Quebec to go off on its own sovereigntist ways, it is both politically motivated and altogether sad. Don't get me wrong, this is a brilliant move on Harper's part, giving him better access to Quebec seats as well as downplaying the possibility of another major sovereignty debate. Granted, it is a concession to even consider Quebec as anything other than just a part of Canada but a necessary one if he was to avoid outright disagreement with the BQ.

Quebec Premier Jean Charest was happy with the announcement and even encouraged the BQ and Quebecers to support Harper's motion. MP Belinda Stronach also voiced her support of Harper's motion stating that it's a move in the right direction if it helps Quebec to "protect its unique culture and identity." I agree, if this is what must be done to appease separatists (though I in no way believe that that's the feeling they have right now), then it must be done. And I recognize that Quebec has a very unique culture and identity having lived there for five years. But having a unique identity does not entitle it, or any other province for that matter, to special treatment as its own nation.

While it is still undetermined as to when Harper will introduce the motion, there will be debate and controversy, but this is really the least of our problems. C'mon now people, let's focus on more important matters like Peace on Earth and Goodwill towards Men.